Wonderskin1440 Longwear Black Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil - Sharpenable Black Eyeliner Pencil and Smudge Proof Eye Liner Pencils (Liquorice)ClimatePartner certified

Update……. I bought a make up sharpener and it worked. So bumped it up to a five star. If you buy it… get the right sharpener.The eyeliner was great for two applications, but then it was impossible to sharpen. It wasn’t the soft product that could be fixed by refrigerating as they suggest, it was the whole outside of the pencil that just wouldn’t sharpen. What a mess! The only reason I gave it two stars was because I liked the two times I was able to wear it.

This is my third purchase and I love it. It glides on smoothly and stays on my lids all day. My eyes are sensitive and water easily, this eyeliner does not irritate my eyes whatsoever.

I have been searching for an eye pencil that didn’t smudge after a couple of hours on my 64 year old eyes. This is the sixth pencil I have tried, and while not perfect, this brown color stays on better and the brown isn’t quite so noticeable when it smudges. I tried the black, too, and it is a very intense black so the smudges are darker, too. Pencil glides on easily. Again, while not perfect, it’s the best I’ve tried, and I’ve tried a number of popular brands.

As well as it is waterproof it is pretty good make sure that you do get exactly how you want it because if you let it dry it's going to take some scrubbing to get off and do not use the same part of the wipe because it will just smear right back on. Honestly I don't think it was worth the money but it kind of is the best waterproof eyeliner I have found. If I wear it literally all day it kind of creates these little Crystal Rock things in my eyelashes and I got to do some scrubbing to get it off I think my average with this eyeliner and the matching mascara is about 3 face wipes. Sometimes it does irritate my eyes but I think that's just me and my contacts I don't really like how it's a pencil I feel like I waste too much for the price every time I got to sharpen it. But it does last quite a freaking bit like a good long minute even in the rain or something like that too crying so I mean is there could be a couple different things to it I would feel like it would be the perfect eyeliner. But $18 for an eyeliner is so ridiculous but I wanted to give it a try and I ultimately am glad that I did

I am in my 60’s, so trust me when I say I’ve tried A LOT of eye liners! This is the first one that actually stays in place without smudging and ending up all under my eyes or above my eyelids. I’ve purchased this in four colors and use it almost daily.

Very soft and once you get it sharpened very easily to apply. Just be aware if you don't have the right sharpener you'll end up wasting a lot of the product.

Love this ! Dark Brown . Perfect shade . Doesn’t smear nor smudge and waterproof. Great Buy

This is a pretty good eyeliner. It's not THE BEST, but it's good. I wish I could find a dark green (Forest Green) eyeliner that ISN'T Metallic... EVERYONE has ONLY METALLIC! I want a MATTE Forest Green... But I'm happy with the eyeliner. I got a few smudges initially, but once I wiped them, it stayed. Also nicely pigmented. It's just the metallic shine bugs me, because from certain angles it looks like it's not all there... (But that's with ANY metallic eyeliner!)