BBIA Last Auto Gel Eyeliner 17 Color – Multi-Use Longwear & Waterproof Mechanical Eye Liner Easy Drawing with Smooth Texture Smudge-Resistant Shadow & Glitter Vegan Korea Eye Makeup (14 ALMOND BEIGE)

Now I’ll preface this by saying that my eyelids aren’t very oily, as it skin is dry in general. That said, this is a great color. After my peripera dried out and I couldn’t find it anywhere anymore, I was on the search for a muted brown with a reddish undertone. I have grey eyes and find black is too overpowering and most browns can also be a bit dark, so I like using brown with wine-ish undertones, or even muted wine colors. This is a great compromise between the two colors I like using. It has serious staying power and a little goes a long way in my opinion. It’s creamy, doesn’t skip or drag, and is super easy to use thanks to the automatic sharpening. Overall, this is easily worth the money as it outperforms even my old prestige liners.

I was originally looking for a plain brown eye pencil liner to create more of a natural, subtle look instead of liquid liner. When this arrived, I was a bit disappointed to figure out there is a lot of glitter, and it’s especially noticeable in brighter lighting. I think it’s cute, just not the look I was going for. Overall, it is a nice, pigmented, and smooth eyeliner pencil and I will be keeping it just because I don’t think the glitter as noticeable in normal lighting. If you’re looking for a completely plain brown pencil, this is not for you

I really like the colors, which are very close to the photos. They are soft so it's quite easy to apply. They need a little touch-up to maintain your makeup all day

I was looking for under eyeshadow. I was perfect color for my skin tone. However, The lead was broken already when it arrived

I have 6 of these, super smooth and blendable, never tugs

I bought 2 of these eyeliners: Rose Brown (03) & Rose Burn (07).Rose Brown is more of copper brown without shimmer.Rose Burn is a terracotta brown without shimmer.Before using these pencils, I suggest lightly rubbing them on paper or a tissue to get rid of the "coating" on the tip. This will soften it a bit and allow the pencil to glide onto the skin much easier.These pencils are applied by stroking them onto the eyeline. You can't really do a solid line in one go. If you do, there is a tendency to chip the tip or even break. Soft strokes along the lash line is the best. It also sets pretty quickly. There isn't really time to smudge it into some smokey line. I also tried it along the waterline but it doesn't stick to it, so that is a bust. The best way to use it is to use it as an eyeliner AFTER you have applied the eyeshadow to allow the color to stick to it.You can also use these pencils on the eyebrows and even on the lips.If you are looking for a soft pencil that glides and gives you time to smudge then this is NOT the pencil for you.If you are looking for pencils which lines the eyes, brows, or lips; then these are the ones for you.I knocked a star off since it can't be used as a smokey smudging liner.

This is a beautiful eyeliner. Rosy brown. It is not as sharp and dark as black. Let your eyes stand out in a soft gentle way. I love it!

Loved the price, but immediately returned this item because the eyeliner is not gel like, is extremely thin, breaks easily, very difficult to create a straight line and smudges. I am Korean American and I take price in Korean products, but was disappointed with this brand of makeup. Maybe it is user error, but it shouldn't be that difficult to apply. Also, the eyeliner should be durable enough to make a smooth line without breaking. Purchase something more expensive that will last