The Oscar Wilde Collection (The Importance of Being Earnest / The Picture of Dorian Gray / An Ideal Husband / Lady Windermere's Fan)
D**2
An Uneven Collection
"The Oscar Wilde Collection" includes four performances of Wilde's works, and a feature on the life of Oscar Wilde. These were all broadcast on the BBC in the past, and they feature several well-known actors, such as Sir John Gielgud, Joan Plowright, Jeremy Brett, Susan Hampshire, Margaret Leighton, and more."The Importance of Being Earnest" is one of Wilde's greatest works. It was first performed in 1895, in the St. James' Theatre in London. However, the performance here is not the original four act version of the play. The written information lists this as being the 1988 production of the play, but the Internet Movie Database shows it as being from 1986, and one can see in the video credits that the 1986 data appears to be correct. This is the story of two men, each of whom use an unreal person to give them an excuse to avoid unwelcome situations. This practice ultimately results in causing more trouble than it avoids for each of them. The performance is good, but far from exceptional. Joan Plowright gives a decent performance as Lady Bracknell."The Picture of Dorian Gray" is a performance based on Wilde's 1891 novel. This production first aired in 1976, and I don't think it is very good at all. The only thing worthwhile is the performance of Sir John Gielgud as Lord Henry Wotton. Of course, this is the one work presented here which is not a play in its original form. The story is of a man (Dorian Gray) who wishes he could stay young like his portrait, and have the portrait grow old in his place."An Ideal Husband" is originally from 1895, and this is my favorite of the four productions included in this collection. First broadcast in 1969, there are several great performances here. Jeremy Brett is wonderful as Vicount Goring, and Margaret Leighton (Mrs. Cheveley), Dinah Sheridan (Lady Chiltern), and Keith Michell (Sir Robert Chiltern) all deliver strong performances as well. The play involves blackmail, political corruption, and the idea that no one should be judged entirely by their past."Lady Windermere's Fan" is a play from 1892. This performance is from 1985, and as with "The Importance of Being Earnest" it is a good, but not great, performance. This play is about the appearance of impropriety which nearly destroys Lord and Lady Windermere's marriage, when she learns that he is spending an unseemly amount of time in Mrs. Erlynne's presence and giving her large amounts of money. Mrs. Erlynne is well played by Stephanie Turner.The feature titled "The Life and Loves of Oscar Wilde" is well done, and provides a great deal of insight into the man and his tragic end.
G**O
"I can resist anything except temptation."
It's nearly impossible to believe that just a century and a few decades ago, people lived, dressed, behaved, spoke as they are portrayed in these four opulent productions of works by Oscar Wilde. But one can't help wondering if they were even half as witty and self-possessed as the characters of Wilde's imagination. Even the dullest duchess is granted a witticism now and then, that has me snatching up my notebook to record it for future recycling. I suppose Wilde must have scribbled such spontaneous repartee on the lining of his velvet jacket, for eventual condensation in dramatic form. I've known some rapier-sharp gay blades here and there, but none with as polished an edge as the typical dissolute dilettante of Wilde's wild imagination.They were a handsome race of people, Wilde's upper-crust Brits in their finery, though perhaps that's a 'willing suspension' of disbelief based on the art of casting and costuming. In effect, it's a tribute to the skillful acting of every figure in these BBC productions, that they all seem utterly plausible as Victorian Britons. Their style, their wit, their sense of 'comme il faut', is such that it makes our current mode seem hideously drab and lax. Yes, yes, "they" were the few, amid throngs of drudges and destitute, and I have no particular desire to dress my wife and daughters (the latter imaginary) in corsets and bustles, or myself in a frock coat, but it does seem that we've "let ourselves go". I fear Oscar Wilde would find us dreadfully lackluster.These four adaptations are a lot of fun, and a blessed relief from "action" films and vampire romance.
S**9
Really Happy to Finally Get This DVD
I'm not really a fan of Oscar Wilde's novels, but this DVD makes me appreciate some of his work. However, there are two major factors that makes me even more pleased. First, this 2-disc DVD package played just fine on my all-region DVD player, and second, I discovered two movies starring one of my all-time favorite legendary actors, Mr. Jeremy Brett! He was most famous and recognized by international viewers for his brilliant portrayal as Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's super sleuth, Sherlock Holmes (the '80s TV series from Granada Studios on ITV UK). He appears in two films: "The Picture of Dorian Gray" as Basil Hallward (the painter of Dorian) from BBC Play of the Month in 1976 and "An Ideal Husband" as Lord Goring from the same BBC show in 1969. Oh joy!! :D
P**A
Excellent performance by the BBC and closer to the novel than any other version.
Very good performance by the BBC and closer to the novel than any other version I have ever seen, although the novel has never been given full justice by any movie or TV adaptation. It is also a lot more gay than other productions which is again more accurate to the novel although surprising for the mid 1970's. The principal actors are EXCELLENT in their rolls and perfectly chosen. Peter Firth as Dorian Gray is the ONLY actor in a movie version who ever looked awesome enough to be the captivating to both sexes Dorian Gray. Sir John Gielgud was of course born for Sir Henry. This one is so very much above the horrible and inaccurate movie version of the 1940s that this one will blow you away by comparison.The only drawback is that the play was originally recorded by the BBC on standard def videotape which looks dated and a little washed out today on full def big screen, but it is impossible to do anything more than has been done in this transfer due to the limitations of the source. Even with that drawback, it is still the best ever released hands down.
H**U
Disappointingly dated BBC drama rather than the sarcastic comedy of Wilde
I bought this knowing that Gielgud had acted superbly in The Importance of Being Ernest, in particular with Edith Evans. Sadly this is a later version in the "dramatically serious" style of the 1970's BBC, and only features Gielgud in Dorian Gray, which was not even an Oscar Wilde play. Along with 80 other Amazon readers, I share the view of amg1900 in calling this production "dated". "Being Ernest" is disappointing if you compare it with the soundtrack of the Gielgud 1947 or 1952 versions available on YouTube. Apparently this version contains additional material that was wisely cut by Wilde, and together with the laboured acting the longer version becomes tedious. I particularly disliked the male actors in "Lady Windermere's Fan". Perhaps the best performance was Osborne's adaptation of "Dorian Gray" but "An Ideal Husband" is also watchable. The "Life and Loves of Oscar Wilde" is worth seeing, but the opinions of distant relatives are irrelevant.I don't understand Amazon's "top reviews" which were short and received no votes, when the negative amg1900 review earned 80 votes and is clearly the opinion of most people. Amazon is further misrepresenting this edition by attributing it to "John Gielgud".
S**H
Excellent DVD collection
I bought this as I had previously read the Picture of Dorian Gray and wanted to see the film. I was very pleasantly surprised with the other 3 DVD's. All 4 films are extremely well made, The importance of Being Earnest is incredibly funny - and has continued to make me laugh during repeat watchings. The other movies are also well crafted dramas with unpredictable story lines that keep you entertained from start to finish. The Oscar Wilde story I found desperately sad. I have now bought this box set for my son as I know he will enjoy it as much as I have.
Z**.
VERY WELL ACTED.
Very enjoyable and superbly acted versions of the four playes. That is how Oscar Wilde intended them to be played. Don't bother with the newer makes as they are quite abysmal.
D**N
A Super package
We have greatly enjoyed seeing the plays. "The Importance of Being Earnest" is a great production, far superior to the more recent film starring Everett, Firth, Dench, Witherspoon etc which plays fast and loose with the original, to no positive effect.It was interesting comparing "An Ideal Husband" to the recent film version. Both are good, but the film alters some details, while the play version appears to omit some.
G**S
BBC Good Olde Memories
This Collection of Good Olde Memories takes you back to the decadent aristocratic drawing rooms of the 1890's England. Lovingly restored for DVD, these plays feature a who's who of great actors of the British stage like Sir John Gielgud and Joan Plowright and many more.I doubt if the modern youth of today would enjoy this collection but am sure our older generation would be thrilled to be able to look back in time. A treat for Grannies and Grandpas to view and really enjoy.
Trustpilot
1 month ago
1 day ago