London Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Pencil Eyeliner, Long-Wearing, Ultra-Smooth, Smudge-Proof, 003, Brown, 0.04oz

Great application my new go to for eyeliner, to me it feels very creamy and smooth easy to use, I wouldn’t call it versatile but the coverage is great I just put it on my upper eyelid and they make my eyes pop! And I love that it comes off with my reusable makeup remover

My mistake! I noticed the bit of sparkle in the listing photos, but I just didn't imagine this pencil would be so GLITTERY. It does glide on smoothly and cleanly. It's easy to control and it certainly stays put. In fact, it stays put so well that there's really no chance to blend or soften it. So you get a clean, hard line with a lot of sparkle in it. Not at all appropriate for a lady my age, but my grandniece loves it. She hopes there's a glittery black one, too.

I bought this to try based on the reviews and also the fact that Rimmel mascaras and eyeliners have worked well for me over the years. When I first used this pencil, it went on smoothly and perfectly, and lasted all day. The color is gorgeous. Not too dark and not too coppery like some other brown liners can be. However, for some odd reason, the pencil now does not work as well as before. I really struggle to get it to go on. Application is patchy and it's hard to correct it and get it looking nice. It's like the pencil has dried out even though the cap is always on. I now just use it to make a light line and then go over it with a different brown liner to build up the color and get that beautiful line I'm wanting. This is the only time I've purchased this Rimmel pencil so I don't know if it's an isolated issue. I may give it another chance and purchase another after I use up this one. Also, I skimmed through other reviews and noticed people complaining about the pencil getting chewed up in the sharpener. Please note, especially if you're new to gel liner pencils, you need a special sharpener designed for these type of pencils as they're tougher than traditional wood liners. This type of pencil is more of a plastic type and standard sharpeners can't cut through the material. I have found that Revlon makes an EXCELLENT sharpener for around $6 and it can be used on both traditional and gel liner pencils. I highly suggest investing in one of these sharpeners for your gel liner otherwise you will end up aggravated and disappointed, as well as out some $$$. Overall, this pencil is worth checking out. I took off one star because of the application issue I mentioned but if the next pencil works better then I'll come back and change my rating.

My all time favorite when the price is right!

Better than the expensive ones

The brown is rich and vibrant. Seems to have a hint of sparkle and I would consider it more of a bronze. I can’t remark yet whether it is actually waterproof. **It will require a sharpener that is specific for a gel.** Even with that , the point is not very precise. It glides very well. But because of that, is soft and breaks, wasting product causing it to need to be sharpened at each use. It would be absolutely ideal if it were the same product in a retractable crayon. This would make it unquestionably 5 star. Because this is the case, you will likely go through much more product, making it comparable to a more expensive crayon.

Goes on smooth and stays on

I've used a lot of liner pencils but this is the fifth one I buy of this brand. It goes on easy, doesn't smudge and this color is perfect with my green eyes and blonde hair. It also stays on all night untill I take it off.

Loving it, I already purchased my 2nd.

Bought this before and I love it

Smudge proof

Good smudge free...stays really long

Great !!