Well People Expressionist Brow Pencil, Defining Brow Pencil For A Natural Finish, Ultra-fine Tip For Total Precision, Vegan & Cruelty-free, Neutral Brown

A nice fine point. Self sharpens. Draws nicely. Stays on skin well, harder to smudge than others. Pencil lasts for a long time. Taupe is light brown, very happy as it can be hard to find shades that are truly lighter than brown, to pair with lighter hair color. Formula is lightweight it does not cause skin itching or irritation.

I couldn’t find a color that perfectly matched but the product itself was great! I have very very dark brown eye brows but they’re not black. I ended up going with the darkest brown I could and it is ok. I was also impressed at how long it lasted. Good value for the money. Also, it applies nicely, giving a natural look.

9/17/26 - UPDATE, I kept this so I could give it a good test before reviewing. The color does not stay for more than an hour or so. It is entirely NOT WORTH THE MONEY. 8/25/26 - preliminary: removed 1 star for not including a brush with this. So far, I like the color. Trying out today and I will report back.

I love this pencil! It stays on really well and works great on my sparse post-chemo eyebrows. 🙌🏼

Update: I'm sad to say that I did not originally notice that you get a much smaller amount of this product compared to others. I ran out in about a month and a half. I originally got this eyeliner on sale for $8 but it's now back to its regular price of $15. As much as I like the product, I can't justify that cost for roughly one third of what I would get from other products, so I've opted not to repurchase and changed my score from a 5 to a 3. Original Review: I'll admit, I didn't expect much from this product for whatever reason. But I needed a new eyebrow pencil, and I wanted a clean option (this rates well on Yuka and EWG). Even though I have medium brown hair, many brown pencils don't look quite right on me. Sometimes I will even choose taupe to make sure it's not too dark, but I went with Neutral Brown on this one because their taupe looked reddish. I'm thrilled with the results of this product. Upon taking it out of the box, I was concerned with how thin it was, but it actually ended up being perfect in helping me create the look I wanted without having to go heavy handed. It also wears well for me throughout the day. the cost on Amazon was almost half what I could get at Target, so it was a no brainer for me to set this up on subscribe and save going forward. I like this even better than ABH, which is a holy grail for many, myself included for many years. If you are on the fence, I'd say give it a try!