tarte tartelette XL tubing mascara – Lash Extensions in a Tube with Peptide, Extra-Bold Buildable Lifted Length & Volume, Smudge-Proof Longwear, Easy-to-Remove, Vegan & Cruelty-Free

I really like this tubing mascara since I could get it in brown. It mostly stays on, sometime some slight flaking, but it provides length and volume, and it's very easy to remove. WINNER.

I love this stuff. Just got my second tube— the first one (trial size!) lasted me just over 6 months. In terms of clumpiness, it seemed about like other mascaras, but i’ve been in the habit of using an eyelash comb as i put it on anyway (it sets pretty quickly). The formula is awesome though— i have sensitive everything and this doesn’t bother me! If it becomes wet too quickly after applying (before it has a chance to dry fully), or if it gets wet in the shower/swimming, it will slide right off. That’s actually how I like to take it off: get it wet in a hot shower and then gently pull it off with a paper towel. It leaves those nice little tubes of goo on the paper, not flakes. Otherwise it’ll stick around for a good while, surviving a moderate cry or a light rain; I use it on my eyebrows too and it rubs off of those a little more quickly in that more prominent location, but as long as I don’t let it rub up on anything it’ll stick around for two or three days. My eyelashes and eyebrows do seem healthier and longer/thicker now after having used it for six months, which I attribute in part to that aspect of avoiding rubbing it off :) but yeah, great stuff. Feels healthy & nourishing. Thanks gang!

This is the first time I’ve used a “tubing” mascara; when you wash your face the mascara comes off in clumps rather than smudges. I can easily wash it with Vanicream face soap and lots of rinsing. I love the way it keeps my lashes lifted all day!!! Possibly the BEST mascara I’ve ever used! (And I’ve used about 50 different types, including many luxury brands)

I really like this mascara, and it’s definitely sweat proof. Super easy to remove too.

Absolutely love this! Best for sweating as it clumps instead of running down the face. It literally rolls off sp nicely if outdoors or in water. Doesn't flake. Best mascara ever made.

Love this product. Goes on nice and stays in place. Removal is easy. I always purchase this. Definitely recommend

About me: mid-forties, and having a lot of issues with mascara transferring to above my upper lids. Grabbed Tarte travel-sized mascara here for $15 ($28 for full-size), and found a full-sized Maybelline the Colossal at a local bargain shop for $4 (normally priced around $9). In the photos, the Maybelline is on my right eye and the Tarte is on the left—first shot is after two coats (with a coat of my favorite primer first), and the second is after wearing for about 12 hours. The Verdict: Both mascaras delivered almost identical length and volume, with only minor end-of-day flaking. Neither transferred to my upper lids. When it came to application, though, the Maybelline brush was definitely the winner—it was easier to control and gave cleaner coverage with less clumping. Even after wiping the Tarte brush twice on a paper towel, it still left too much product on my lashes. Normally I’m a bit of a product snob, but the Maybelline costs half as much, works just as well, and applies more smoothly. Bonus points if you can find it on clearance, like I did—I’ll definitely be heading back to grab another tube before they run out! Regarding the Tarte XL - 4 stars for the product itself, but I’m dropping my rating to 3 stars for value and ease of use.

For years I used magnetic eyelashes because I am a person that is mindful of the chemicals I put in/on my body. The company that supplied the eyelashes discontinued them so I’ve had to find alternative options. I came across this mascara while at Ulta and it is now my go-to each morning. I won’t echo the same pros as many of the other reviewers but instead, give tips and insight on using this product. Toxicity: EWG gives this product a low 3 rating & states each ingredient is listed is of low hazard. Application: Goes on smoothly with first layer + adds length. Does tend to clump with each subsequent layer. I personally believe one layer is adequate. You can get even longer lashes by applying more layers but it will start to clump and you’ll end up with 6-8 really thick (but long!) eye lashes. I do not like that look so 1 layer it is for me. If your product clumps during that first application, then your product is old/bad. I only buy the small tube because the product always goes bad before it’s empty; even the smaller tube. I also do not “pump” the brush as this introduces air into the tube, drying it out quicker. Easy removal: To remove, all I have to do is wet my eyelashes and the product separates from the lash. I then wet my hands and gently “pull” the mascara off my lashes. No makeup remover needed. I personally despise makeup remover as it’s another product I have to worry about chemically & always burns my eyes regardless of ingredients. Because this mascara is so easy to get off, just know it is NOT waterproof. For my needs, that was perfectly fine.

Feels very light vs. loreal lash paradise that makes me feel sleepy and heavy eyed after application. This one separates and curls lashes nicely without clumping. Only negative is it doesn't volumize a lot. I'm going to use it as my everyday mascara since it's so gentle and removal is easy. No smudging or lash loss at all.