stila Stay All Day Smudge & Set Waterproof Gel Eyeliner | Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner Pencil for Tightline & Waterline, Smudge-Proof Waterproof, Smooth Glide Buildable Color, Cruelty-Free

I am so happy to have found this pencil in gilded green. I have amber eyes and this color is perfect for them. A long time ago I had an eyeliner pencil very similar to this but the brand stopped making it. I kind of gave up on ever finding it again but came across this by sheer luck. It’s a gorgeous vintage looking green with tiny sparkles. It looks super pretty on the bottom waterline. I’ve used lots of Stila eyeliner pencils and they’ve all been great. Love the brand and quality. Lasts all day on me, doesn’t smudge unless you intentionally smudge it for a smoky look and the colors have all been really nice. The pencil is kind of creamy but not too soft. Sharpens well and there’s not a lot of waste from having to sharpen it too frequently. The wood sharpens well too without splinting or having any sharp edges. They do not irritate my sensitive eyes or dry out my skin. I am an older makeup girlie (57) and these still look good on me even with the sparkles. So if you’re older I recommend you go for it. It’s super flattering and easy to use.

Excellent eyeliner- meant to get black but kept this. Dries fast, and mostly stays put/no raccoon eyes. It smudges in the right way, the lines are sharp, and it’s easy to use. I’m getting another- even crying didn’t budge this stuff.

I am older and it took this long to find the just about perfect eyeliner. This eyeliner really does go on smoothly...and it stays on too. Just after a few seconds, it stays. My eyes tend to water a lot, a real challenge fir eyeliner, but this one has staying power. Looks great too. On the expensive side, but if you want to splurge, this one is worth it.

Really pretty color and stays on all day as it says. Doesn't smudge or run

The color is stunning. Held up for most of the day. Didn’t last in my waterline but stayed put on the upper eyelid. Was smooth going on. Did not flake or irritate my eyes.

Definitely stays in place. I love the quality of it,, no eye irritation (and I wear contacts). Can make thin or tho m line, water resistant and sharpens well.

For this price it should be working wonders. It comes off easily and no matter how many times I apply it you can barely see it and I have light skin

This is perfect for a "soft brow" eyebrow filler. Your eyebrows look full and natural, and not too dark. Perfect for people who's hair gets lighter in the summer. Use very light, short strokes.

I bought this as ai like a very fine point crayon eye liner. It wears well and doesn't migrate through the day. The brown leans warm and us very subtle, which I prefer.

Brilliant eyeliner. Soft on the skin. Great colour & lasts all day

This is an awesome eye liner. It stayed on all day. It did smudge later but I was rubbing it.

I love the colour of the gilded green, it’s exactly as described and looks lovely on. It glides on easily and is very pigmented. For me, it doesn’t seem to stay all day though. I have hooded eyelids and it rubs off onto my upper eyelid through the day. I prefer more of a subtle look so it doesn’t bother me too much.

Love this StilaAll Day Smudge and Set Waterproof Gel Eyeliner in Lionfish Bronze. There’s not too much bronze so it’s a lovely melding of brown and bronze. Easy to apply, creamy & smooth, it lives up to its waterproof, longevity claim. Yes it’s a bit pricey but for the quality and colour, it’s worth it. Recommend!