LAURA GELLER NEW YORK INKcredible Gel Eyeliner (Blackbird) Waterproof & Smudge-Proof Pencil With Built in Sharpener For Expert Precision, Glides On Effortlessly, Gel Eyeliner Pencil

Very good, easily applied

Good overall cover lasted all day

Nice soft eyeliner, great pigmentation, easy to apply with a sharpener for precise lining. Easy to use. You have a bit of play time if you make a mistake before it sets. It was not irritating to the eyes and stays in place when applied on waterline. I have hooded oily eyelids. Which is always problematic for eyeliner. I always cleanse and prime but all eyeliners including this one, unfortunately smudge, even after waiting for them to set. But this only happens when I apply above the lash line. However for me, this liner doesn't budge when tightlining or lining the water line, it stays put until you take it off. Laura Gellar make up is always good value for money, the quality is great.

Have bought numerous waterproof eyeliners over the years. Product is fine but on me, the definition tends to fade a bit during the day. Goes on smoothly.

Very goof, would buy again

I bought the brown eyed girl colour last year and it was great. It looked the same as advertised. Last week I used the order again button on my account but what arrived was much shorter and looked nothing like the first one. The product packaging was unsealed and when I tried to use the pencil it was really dry and kept breaking. Was it old stock? The colour was more of a reddish brown and made me look like I had conjunctivitis. Such a shame as I now feel it’s money wasted and a bit of a lottery to buy again.

Lovely gold colour that goes on easily and stays put all day.

So disappointed with this eyeliner, I use other Laura Geller products and am more than pleased, but this eyeliner smudges if you can get it to stay on.

Glides on so smooth! Lasts all day and looks great. Great product for the money!

Goes on so smoothly. Try not to make a mistake though. Stays on All Day.

This eye liner glides on very easy and looks great. It is smudge proof and easy on the eyes, very good quality! I am very pleased with this product as I have been with all of the products I have ordered from Laura Geller New York!! I would highly recommend this product!!

Great color, goes on smoothly. Great daytime color option as opposed to a harsh black

Haven't tried the sharpener yet but love this eyeliner. What I love is that I only have to apply it every other day, sometimes less because it IS so waterproof! I only line my lower lashes so this definitely fills my need for eyeliner. It stays where you put it. The color Graphite works well with my complexion, eye color and really white hair (okay, and my age - no need to look like Amy Winehouse). Watching the price because I would love to experiment with another color.