Wonderskin Eyeliner Pencil, 1440 Longwear Deep Black Eyeliner Pencil - Waterproof, Sharpenable & Smudge Proof (Liquorice)

I'm 75 years old and this is by far the best pencil eyeliner I have ever used, aside from another brand. It glides on even with a touch of oily eyelid. Wait for a few seconds & it sets. I bought 2 more. The tip does not break off as my other ones, since I don't need to press hard. Creamy texture & the colors are same as shown. Expensive, but it's well worth it.

The Wonderskin 1440 Eyeliner goes on smoothly with amazing color payoff and sets quickly. It’s perfect for winged liner, tightlining, or a soft smudge if you work quickly before it sets. Plus, it feels lightweight and comfortable, not dry or stiff. Once it’s on, it truly does not smudge or transfer — even after wearing it all day. It stays in place and still looks fresh hours later. Suffice it to say, it looks SO good that my boyfriend thought I had my fake lashes on, lol, and all I did was tightlining!! I love this eyeliner and already have 5 color options for my blue eyes. Get yours today!

I have tested soooo many eyeliners. I wear my liners on the waterline exactly and most cannot stay due to the water. This eyeliner stays butttt it depends on what other things you put on your face first. Depending on your make up or face creams it will affect the staying power. If done right, the liner stays all day for me especially in colder less humid temperatures. My biggest reason for giving it four starts is that it’s an old school sharpen. Very inconvenient. Very dated. I’d pay more to get a twist format where I don’t need a sharpener and lost a big chunk of my liner when it gets too small to sharpen.

The Wonderskin Longwear Eyeliner Pencil glides on smoothly and delivers rich, intense color that lasts all day without smudging. I love that it’s waterproof and sharpenable, making it easy to create precise lines that stay in place from morning to night.

I am always super suspicious of things I see on social media. I always have issues with eyeliner smudging and ending up below my eyes after a few hours. Not this one. I got home from work and it was on my front porch. I tried it out. First, it glides on, which is great for "mature" skin. You can gently apply without any tugging or dragging. It dries quickly and STAYS. I slept in it. Woke up the next morning and it looked like I had just applied it. What?!?! Amazing. Not that I ever recommend sleeping with eye make up on but for this test, it was worth it. Highly recommend. The Kalamata color is beautiful. I don't think I will ever buy a different brand of eyeliner.

I’ve been using this eyeliner daily for about a week. I love the color and how easily it applies. I always apply it to clean eyelids and a dry upper waterline. I’ve tried adjusting the application by going thinner and thicker, and I even let it fully dry before opening my eyes — but unfortunately, it still fades completely after just a few hours. Because of all the hype around this product, I had high expectations. I don’t have watery eyes and I don’t rub or touch my eyes throughout the day, so I was really disappointed with how poorly it held up. I wanted to love this eyeliner, but the staying power just isn’t there for me.

I would say this is a pretty good eyeliner. I saw an add on Facebook promoting this and really wanted to try it. It goes on smooth and looks great but it does still smudge. Maybe not as bad as other eyeliners but It did run on the inner corner of my eyes like other eyeliners. It does look fantastic though!

I've tried so many other brands that claimed to be water-resistant/waterproof, long-lasting, smudge-proof, etc but weren't.. Almost all of them ended up under my eyes, or caused my eyes to water (even the hypoallergenic brands). My eyes are small, kind of deep set, and I have very hooded eyelids. I like to line the upper (and half of the bottom) inner waterlines. I wear moisturizer, concealer and foundation, and within the first 30 minutes, I always ended up with eyeliner under my eyes that I was constantly wiping off. This eyeliner does not do that!! It glides on very very smoothly, and stays where you want it! My eyes water when I laugh sometimes, or due to allergies, but didn't water immediately after use like other brands cause. It really starts put !! I've even forgotten and rubbed my eye, and it was still there. I've even slept in it and it's still there the next morning. I'm not crazy about the price, but it's worth it to have finally found an eyeliner that actually does what it says. The only thing negative I can say is that it's *slightly* harder to remove (using makeup remover wipes), and I do worry about how it'll work out once I've had to sharpen it. This one's a winner!