Eyeliner Pencil 1440 Longwear Eyeliner Waterproof & Smudge Proof | Waterproof deep black eyeliner, smudge-proof formula glides on smoothly for precise, long-lasting definition.

I live in the South and when it’s hot and humid my eyeliner is all over the place. I was dubious when I bought this eyeliner, but let me tell you, it lives up to the hype! I bought it in multiple colors and they are not just long lasting, they are vibrant. It glides on smoothly too. I’ve seen some people complain that it’s hard to take off, but I’m old school and Pond’s Cold Cream takes it right off. If I could give it 10 stars I would!

Absolutely love this eyeliner. It lasts for so long and it easy to apply on my waterline. I also am a woman using my dad’s account just so you know hahaha! Anyway this eyeliner can be difficult to sharpen without the tip breaking off so what you’ll want to do is chill it before sharpening!

So far I’m enjoying this eyeliner but if you’re looking for clean/ precise lines, this isn’t it. Pros: The formula is VERY creamy and goes on easily, it stays in place once it sets for about 20 seconds or so. Cons: when using this formula there is a learning curve that not everyone will have the patience for. Sharpening can be a pain and really messy. The tip breaks easily and the bits that come off will stain everything it touches including your skin and clothing. Because of that, getting a sharp point is difficult and expensive and it doesn’t last more than a few swipes. It also clumps up in your eyelashes when you try to fill in the space between your lid and waterline and you have to be quick about correcting your mistakes (I suggest getting the sharp Qtips meant for manicures). It does smear/ run if your eye gets watery. The video I took is self explanatory aside from the last line, I used an oil based face cleanser to remove that line. As for the pictures, the first is right after I applied it, the second was after I slept with in on (specifically for this review), and the last was after I used the oil based cleanser to remove it. All in all, yes there are more cons but I enjoy how dark it is and the way it makes my eyes look once I have it on. I’ve been using a liquid liner to clean up the edges and I think with time and experience it will get easier to apply.

This eyeliner does stay put for the most part but not NEARLY as well as claimed. All the ads show that it stays well along the water line, and they really make a big deal about that, but it absolutely does not. I let mine dry completely and within an hour it was smudged under my eye. On the lid it goes on very “slippery” almost like a liquid so you have to be extra careful applying. It dries a little crusty, but not uncomfortable, but it doesn’t last on the inside and outside corners nearly as well as my $6 ELF No Budge. And the $6 eyeliner doesn’t dry crusty. After an entire night I still had the center of my eye lined, and that lasted overnight, looking just as good as before I went to bed. But I still had to reapply at the inside and outside corners. (A family emergency had me crashing on my parents couch and getting up super early, so yes I slept in my makeup and only had time for a quick refresh) Overall I wouldn’t recommend against it, but I’m going to stick with my No Budge at 1/3 the price.

I honestly love this eyeliner. It works better than any other waterproof eyeliner I've ever bought & used. It is hard to remove. I use a eye make up remover for false eyelashes that works great. So does a soap I use, called Dr. Ohhira Kampuku bar. (you can buy it at Sprouts) I can be tricky to figure out how to get it to wear the best. I smudge mine and lightly dust with eyeshadow. I live in Utah, during the super hot summer months when It's melting temperatures outside like I'm at the gates of hell, (Today was 105 in Salt Lake City) It can move a bit from time to time. But it still works a million times better than any other "waterproof eyeliner I've ever used. I have every color. I like to mix them. My favorite combo is the back with eggplant or pine over it.

I will never buy any other kind of eyeliner. Love that it slides on easily, does not smear or fade hours into wearing it on my water line. Love love love this wonderskin eyeliner

I wont say this is a 12 hour wear. Not by any means. But I will say it stays on longer than the hour (if that) my other eyeliner would wear (in the waterline). Ill actually have this on for several hours, bold. Its not wiping off before I even get into the car. I wear this for my waterline, not my eye lid. It is smooth as silk, a good bold black, goes on in almost one swipe, not irritating to my eyes, doesnt flake. I use micellar water to remove my make up and it doesnt require extra scrubbing. I like this eye liner a lot, and have been showing it to friends and family. Will order again.

I really love this eyeliner. PROS: This eyeliner literally lasts all day and no need to reapply. CONS: Sharpening this pencil is horrific. I've tried multiple different makeup sharpeners, and none work well enough. I think Wonderskin made this eyeliner to be non-sharpen-able. Sucks. Sharpening it just eats up the pencil and breaks the actual eyeliner. For the high price, it's terrible. I hope the company can make this better like in a retractable pencil.

Amazing eyeliner! I have been on the search for an eyeliner for the waterline that applies creamy, deeply pigmented and actually lasts...and this is the closest I've found! It doesn't last all day, I may touch up once throughout a 14hr period, but this is way less than any other brand I've tried (including MAC and RareBeauty) which I would need to touch up 4-5x. I will be buying more. Love love love!

The product doesn’t come with the sharpener it’s worst and not worth 100aed it smudges when you sharp with your available tool.. it’s highly fragile it Breaks quickly after shaping… the worst product this must be banned on amazon

Super tiens bien

It does smug the hype is not real

Excellent product did what was stated stayed on all day and did not run