Salt Water Taffy10 Flavor Assortment Salt Water Gluten Free Kosher (4 LB)

This is proper saltwater taffy after four tries. It shouldn't be too sweet. The fake stuff is pure sugar. Also, it's supposed to be different flavors. Not just different colors. Most "saltwater taffy" these days is same tasting but different colors. That feels like a ripoff. So it was awesome that each different color has a proper different flavor. Also, while not being a huge licorice fan (the white with black striped pieces) are the first licorice flavored thing I've ever liked in my life because of how mild it is. The red flavor is the best, but they are all good. I'll probably end up buying this brand regularly.

I haven't had salt water taffy in a very long time and started craving it recently, so shopped around for a pack of it. I was pleased to find a large bag of assorted flavors like this! It tastes just as good as I remembered too. There is a note on the bag saying that some bags may not contain all flavors, and that is unfortunately the nature of packaging assorted candy sometimes! I luckily had all flavors but I wouldn't have been too pressed had I not. I like all of them except for the cinnamon, I just gave those to my roommate since he enjoys them and I didn't want them going to waste. The only real downside of ordering salt water taffy online is if you order during any time of the year when its hot out, the taffy might melt some. A few pieces I had did melt a little but it wasn't a big deal, they were still wrapped but just a little bit seeped out. Still edible, still delicious. Also just gonna say I am laughing at the person in the review who gave it a low rating because there's "no salt water". Salt water taffy isn't made with seawater to begin with, though recipes do tend to include water and salt in them. The origin of the name "salt water taffy" has yet to truly be determined, as there are quite a few stories that have gone around but they are apocryphal at best.

Normally I would give this product 5 stars because I really do enjoy this taffy. This time only a 4 because, unfortunately, this bag did not have a single piece of the pear flavor (my favorite). This was a real bummer.

I was given a bag of this for my birthday in February which did not last long, then my friends bought me 2 more bags for Mothers Day! Disappeared very fast also. Now I read of a few problems people had with shipping so I just want to add that I received this in an Amazon box in the middle of the afternoon, and even in the higher than usual heat, there was only a few pieces out of the entire bag of 4# that were stuck together. We put the bag in the frig as precaution and within minutes the "stuck" pieces came apart and we ATE them. We always divide the big into gallon zip bags since there is only 2 of us here...well 3 counting my "rat terrier". She is almost 16 and has lost a couple teeth, but can chew the taffy if we roll it in 2 little balls. And I did check on ebay as someone suggested on here....this bag is going for over $30.00 and some people are charging $15-$30 shipping. If you want to try great taffy this is it and this is the best price I can find especially since I had it in less than 2 days! Enjoy!

I do not recommend this product. Almost all the taffy’s were so sticky, you cannot even unwrap them. I discarded the product as unable to unwrap. Very disappointed.

Got my taffy a few days early its just the same as the smaller first bag I bought 10 wonderful flavors. No sticky or stuck together candy all are in great condition. Bought the 4LB bag, yum ! This saves money on a long run and fun for me. I do like the taste of this brand they melt in your mouth also soft & chewy if you go that way.

This bag is huge. Which is why I bought it because I fo through a 1/2 pound a day 😂 I get on obsessions of candy and stay on it for a few months. This is my obsession again. Softness is perfect. Tastes delicious especially my favorite the cinnamon. Freshness is great. No hardness to ti. Variety is great in this Huge 5 lb bag. I didn't realize how big the bag was until it came. It melts in your mouth.

I personally dont care for the flavors. The cinnamon ones are too spicy. A lot of flavors I cant identify and most I dont like. They are also too hard to get out of the paper. I wish I had ordered just the banana flavored ones.