Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats, Creamy Dairy, 3 oz, 12pk

Cats love it.

It seems a lot of people have had tragic consequences from their cats eating these treats and I am truly heartbroken for you all. I have 4 cats, but this really concerns the two of my oldest cats. Both will be 18 this year, both black, formerly 20lbs each but not siblings. Zell had diabetes a few years back but now is cured. Monkey has hyperthyroidism and is just a shadown of his former self. I feed all of my cats grain-free dry cat food and grain-free wet cat food, along with Fancy Feast wet recommend by my vet. Monkey won't touch the dry food, won't eat a lot of the wet but will eat handfuls of Temptations treats. I am just desperately trying to keep him alive at just 6+lbs with treats, which are at least nutritionally complete and medication. His blood work is fine except for the thyroid and occasional liver enzymes. He had fatty liver disease 8 years ago, which I nursed him through and after he gained his weight back, was attacked by two stray dogs who ripped him from belly to anus. I have fought so hard to keep this cat alive and if Temptations is mostly all he will eat, then that's what he will get. This has been going on for three years. I do not feed the seafood flavors of anything to Monkey because of the higher iodine/mercury content. I do limit my other cats consumption of these treat, mostly for weight issues but rarely do I have a problem aside from the occasional vomiting and the younger two have never been ill a a day in their 4 and 6 year-old lives. Zelly, is in good health other than sleeping more than he used to but he's an old man kitty now. Which is to be expected. If I could get my Monkey to eat something else, other than a little wet food I would but I have tried everything including kitten food, kitty Ensure, tubed weight gain gel and homemade cat food with little to no sucess. I would never feed any of my cats Whiskas food and I hate giving them Fancy Feast, the classic and cheesey bits only because of the soy protein in some types. Temptations are the only thing keeping Monkeyshines alive, so Temptations it is. That is our story

Run a rescue and this Dairy flavor is the most favored... We've tried 'em all. This and the Chicken are the most appreciated.. other flavors sometimes have pieces left... there's no pieces left when these are given. If your gang is like most other kitties... I think these will be their favorites also. Try to get 'em on sale. The usual price is a bit of a "gouge"....

My three cats absolutely love these treats!

Our cats have loved Temptations for many years. But I noticed that my latest purchase (Oct. 2025) has a different, rougher finish, and the cats clearly don't like them as well as they have until now. So it appears the formulation and/ or manufacturing process has been changed. Not sure why they would screw with the successful kitty crack recipe.

The dairy flavor is the favorite for my two picky cats. If I am lucky, I can find this for about 10 cents more at my local Safeway, but usually they are out or did not reorder for this cycle. Purchasing the large pack with free shipping was a budget saver and my cats are very happy.

I buy lots of Temptations flavors for my 5 cats. One package is plenty for treating them to a little something special. The Creamy Dairy flavor looked new and I had never tried it, so I purchased a 12 pack box. All of my cats cleaned up the treat table with them. They were shipped in a really tight carton, and I can't remember getting even one broken piece! And, of course, being a Prime customer, they came ultra quickly! I will continue to buy this flavor along with the other flavors. I have not found one my cats do not like, but they seem to like the Dairy Flavor just a little more than the others.....

Our cat loves these Temptations treats. This is his favorite flavor, although he likes many of the other flavors. We used to buy them in supermarkets and Target, but they either stopped selling them or the price went way up. I did some calculations and found that getting these mega bags with free shipping is the same cost as the price we used to pay, which is .51 per ounce. Most of the offerings for these treats on Amazon have the per ounce price right next to the item price. So, it's easy to compare. Our cat highly recommends them, 2 paws up.