Sherlock - Series 4 [DVD] [2016]
D**D
I'm so so SO very happy with this.
I had been a bit nervous when looking forward to seeing this fourth series of Sherlock. There had been so many bad reviews about it in advance of its final arrival in Germany. But - now that I've seen the complete series twice, all i can say is: Those reviewers have got it all wrong!I will not have spoilers in this, as there are so many better episode guides already available.As far as the acting goes - I think that Cumberbatch and Freeman are even better - much better in fact - than they've been in series 1-3 and the Christmas Special. I think all the experience with different roles, different kinds of movies and different directors has taught them quite a bit. Gatiss' performance has much improved too. I liked him and his interpretation of Mycroft from the start, but now he's even better. There is a depth of character to his Mycroft now that wasn't there before.Toby Jones and Sian Brooke in their respective roles I found perfectly casted. There is, if I'm forgiven for adding one little bit of a spoiler here - a slight chance of Mycroft finding a love interest of his own.As to the stories - I cannot for the life of me share the opinion that the scripts are "self-indulgent" or "ridiculous" or "dumb" or "ridiculous" or whatever else I'd read about them before I even got the DVD. On the contrary, I find them coherent, logical and psycologically fascinating. Especially the "blend" of bits from Doyle's original stories like "The Musgrave Ritual" or "The Dying Detective" with the modern story line is, for me, a perfect fit. This is the story that Arthur Conan Doyle should have, but has never told. How Sherlock Holmes, this bundle of contradictions, has become the man he is. How a man can be a perfect misanthrope but at the same time have enough empathy to see through the most complex emotional or psychological motives for crimes. How he can be merciless enough to humiliate and ridicule his fellow men on many occasions, but at the same time have pity on a loving couple, or on a whining hotel thief. Why he would need cocaine to drown his bouts of "boredom" - because there's more coming up in his mind once he's not busy than just some pains of dullness. How he can be a perfect solitaire when he at the same time craves a friend like John in his life.I admit the stories are told not chronologically and not in one, continuous story line. They're told in bits and pieces, like a mosaique. However, I enjoyed that incredibly because it was so very well done. It made my second round with the DVDs as enjoyable as the first. If, of some people, this is too much demanded, they might wish to look out for another show. There are enough shows that tell one coherent story in one definte line. You could even have a little nap in between and wouldn't have any trouble tuning in again afterwards. But that's not what and how Sherlock is. Arthur Conan Doyle's stories are not like that, so why would the TV series be?The production design is much darker now than it has been in series 1-3. Even darker than that of The Abominable Bride. there are, for me at least, some marvellous quotes from the last two James Bond movies. For one, there's the ancient and stately home of the Holmes family, Musgrave Hall that very much looks like Skyfall, the ancient home of the Bond family. And there are those unsolved childhood mysteries and/or the early misdeeds nobody has ever atoned for that came to haunt James Bond (in "Skyfall" and in "Spectre").All in all - the fourth series of Sherlock has the feeling of an end as well as that of a beginning to it. Here ends the story of "Becoming Sherlock Holmes" and here starts the story of "Being Sherlock Holmes". I like that especially as last year's "Mr Holmes" with Ian McKellen has told me the story of "having been Sherlock Holmes."I so very much hope that Cumberbatch and Freeman and Gatiss and all the others will still give me a fifth, a sixth, a twelfth and a twentieth series of "Sherlock". I have a feeling that I can no longer live without him.
J**R
CONTROVERSY
Series Four was the work of the same team that created the first three-and-a-half series:-- Written by Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss, who are responsible for eleven of the thirteen episodes of "Sherlock" broadcast since 2010.-- All supporting characters return for Season Four:---- Mark Gatiss as Mycroft Holmes---- Rupert Graves as Inspector Lestrade---- Una Stubbs as Mrs. Hudson---- Amanda Abbington as Mary Morstan Watson---- Louise Brealey as Molly Hooper---- Andrew Scott as Moriarty (he just won't stay dead - this is not really a spoiler: Moriarty never stays dead. Basil Rathbone killed him off three times to no avail).Despite this pedigree, a lot of reviewers on Amazon hated Series Four, especially "The Final Problem"This is in contrast to the three previous series, which were greeted with Universal Rapture.Amazon Ratings (March 2017):-- Series 1 = 92% positive, 5% negative (575 reviews)-- Series 2 = 95% positive, 4% negative (539 reviews)-- Series 3 = 90% positive, 6% negative (1,063 reviews)-- Series 4 = 69% positive, 22% negative (137 reviews)-- Abominable Bride = 72% positive, 21% negative (341 reviews)positive = four or five stars , negative = one or two stars (not many three star reviews for Sherlock)-- No commentary tracks, but the Blu-Ray/DVD includes ten bonus features totaling 1 hour, 49 minutes, 25 seconds.-- All four-and-a-half seasons of "Sherlock" are English SDH subtitled for the hard-of-hearing.-- The first publicity photos for Season Four show new cast members Baby Watson and Toby the Bloodhound.Despite it's title, "The Final Problem" is the only one of thirteen "Sherlock" episodes not based (at least loosely) on a Conan Doyle story.The Series Four finale veered strongly in the direction of horror/science fiction.As an elderly gentleman, I prefer my mysteries straight.Nevertheless, as mystery/horror/science fiction, it was extremely well done.No regrets about giving the fourth season five stars.OBSCURE REFERENCES:There are a lot of references to the original stories.The most obscure one ever is @ 57:01 of Episode One "The Six Thatchers":Two Norwegian fishing boats are moored at a dock.Freeze the picture and zoom in.The boats are named "Flekkete Band" and "Lovens Manke" ("The Speckled Band" and "The Lion's Mane")Movie reference: In the 1970 Billy Wilder film "The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes", a mysterious Belgian woman, Gabrielle Valladon, begs Holmes to find her missing husband.As part of the investigation, Sherlock and Gabrielle pose as husband and wife: "Mr. and Mrs. Ashdown"."Gabrielle Ashdown" is the alias on the forged passport used by Mary Watson in "The Six Thatchers".In the final scene, Holmes and Watson emerge from a building labeled "Rathbone Place".Rathbone Place is an actual street in LondonIt's been there since the Eighteenth Century, so it wasn't named after Basil.The building used in "Sherlock" is actually somewhere in Wales.Watch the bonus feature "Behind 221B The Final Problem":@ 21:45 you can see a woman gluing a "Rathbone Place" sign to the building.-- If you are new to "Sherlock", there is a new ten disc boxed set of everything at a reduced price.Available in DVD or Blu-Ray:Sherlock - Series 1-4 & Abominable Bride Box Set [DVD] [2016]orSherlock - Series 1-4 & Abominable Bride Box Set [Blu-ray] [2016]SPOILER - DON'T READ THIS PARAGRAPH UNTIL AFTER YOU HAVE VIEWED THE FIRST EPISODE:The second biggest controversy seems to be the death of Mary Watson in Episode One.The TV writers are getting a bum rap here:It was Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's idea to kill her off.Watson met Mary Morstan (not an assassin/secret agent) in 'The Sign of Four' (published 1890).They married, and for the next several stories Watson moved out of 221B Baker Street.Readers were not happy.Conan Doyle noticed.By the time 'The Norwood Builder' was published (1903), it is revealed that Mary has passed away (off-stage) and Watson has moved back into 221B.
C**E
indications faisant défaut
Aucune traduction ni sous-titres autres qu'en anglais
H**Y
Très bien
Rien à redire, cette série est culte et excellente !
S**A
IN ANTICIPO E IN OTTIME CONDIZIONI
Non sto a descrivere la celebre serie perchè se viene acquistata credo che si conosca il contenuto. Comunque serie celebre e molto appassionante, consegnata in anticipo in ottime condizioni. Del resto è un blu ray, non c’è molto da aggiungere.
M**Z
Excelente!!!
Secuela de una excelente serie británica que cuenta con grandes estrellas e historias interesantes que mantienen a la audiencia pendientes de la trama.
S**Y
I enjoyed Season 4
Sherlock season 4 is quite interesting. Sherlock is more human (though still as obnoxious, insensitive, and infuriating to poor Watson). We get a more well rounded look at Watson and we get to see his conscience at work (his Jiminy Cricket). Mycroft cares more about human life than I expected; not such a reptile with romantic interests brewing in the background (maybe for Sherlock too). A new character is introduced, a scary character who does not understand human emotion but seems to have a bond with Sherlock. I'm looking forward to Season five. I hope they do some other Sherlock Holmes stories like, The Red headed league, The Adventure of the Cardboard Box, The Illustrious Client, and the Three Gables.
Trustpilot
2 months ago
3 days ago