Walter Benjamin: A Critical Life

I am filing a minority report. Make no mistake, this is a competent biography of a difficult person who produced work that never yields to clarity, and so this book provides a service. And I have to say, I was constantly mindful of being in the hands of the person who translated the Arcades Project into English. I felt my appreciation continually, and always was aware that the authors were people who were dedicated to Benjamin, maybe in a way that neither Adorno, Horkheimer or Scholem were. Maybe the dedication of these authors was only equaled by Benjamin's wife (forever -- despite the divorce) Dora.My reservation stems from two sources. First, I felt a dissociation between the life events of the man and the work. Maybe this is not only unavoidable with a person such as Benjamin, and maybe it is a matter of producing a biography that is approachable by a wider audience than admiring specialists. But still, I couldn't help but feel that given the sheer power of Benjamin's work and the sheer will (to) power to write and, most of all to THINK, despite the excruciating adversities Benjamin faced there wasn't some connecting thread or theme that could have been elucidated. As a result, I felt that the accounts of the events in Benjamin's life became monotonously repetitious (even the flight from the Nazi's seemed to be just an intensification of the usual travails of poverty and homelessness), and the expositions on his works were stridently schematic.Which brings me to the second concern: it seems to me that the theological dimension of Benjamin's life and work was strangely absent. The "theological" seems to me to be the driving locus of his thought, and the only "reserve" in which Benjamin carved out a byway (a tunnel?) to a future. That this "future" of his never escaped the theological lent to his work that "messianic" cast that anyone who reads Benjamin has too grapple with. That "theological" stream or strain of thought forms the basis for the friendship and struggles between him and Scholem (for whom the religious and Messianic were preset and solved). The precious little attention paid to Benjamin's affinities to theological themes -- Jewish, Messianic, mystical, eschatological, redemptive and textual -- seems strange.I see Benjamin being drawn to the theological as his only connection to the sense of there being a "future" at all. This "prophetic" detachment from material exigency seems to offer a powerful theme on which to lay out his biographical course. The unreality of his love triangles and his inability to extricate himself from culturally collapsing interwar Europe seems bound up with this deep commitment to honor the "mourning" that lends depth, feeling and Kierkegaardian faith to life, but that also renders materialist futurity as a blurred obscurity, if not conceptually entangled impossibility. He could not envision that any border would open up for him, no less the day after he committed suicide.Maybe the authors leave this missing stream or theme to the reader's devices to construct. But I can't help but feel that the book did not quite reach my own mourning for the work and loss of Benjamin.

This is a thick book that delves into the life and above all the writings of Walter Benjamin over more than 600 pages. The authors do an excellent job recreating the intellectual growth of this great thinker while including the details of a complex and ultimately deeply sad life. I'm not sure if I yet understand Benjamin as a person but I appreciate this illuminating, measured look into his life and tragic times.

This is a thoughtful and detailed review of the writing and the life of Walter Benjamin. His monument at Portbou gives some insight into a life that was every bit as tragic as the times he lived in. Curiosity led me to know what happened to him and why his thinking was such a threat to the forces of evil and division that dominated European Society at that time. With Brexit and Catalan separatists, Donald Trump, ISIS and many more, it seems that we are destined to repeat the mistakes that led to the death of this very fine man. The book arrived in good condition and it took only 10 days from order to delivery. Well done Amazon

I picked up this 800 plus page book from the table in the book store attracted by the title, A Critical Life. As I read page after page I learned more and more about not only modernity through the eyes of Walter Benjamin, pronounced Ben ya Mean, but also history of the early and mid-twentieth century viewed through the eyes of intellectuals who had the courage to comment on the woes of society.This book written by professors from Princeton and Harvard reads like a novel. The writing is clear and concise, a challenging task given the complexity of the subject of this autobiography, the son of a well-to-do family who could be described as a geek but who was a charismatic and courageous man.I am richer for picking up the book from the bookstore table.

walter benjamin remains one of the 20th centurys major literary critical figures... certainly one with both credential beyond the academy, and a life ended tragically enough to insure an enduring post mortem fame. the book is a fine one, and well detailed. the benjamin who emerges is initially the bookish son of a successful businessman. the father and the son soon seperate over benjamin's inability to get a job- and benjamin, as the nazi's come to power, begins a life of nomadic penury,marked by his amazing literary output, and which will end with his suicide at port bau in spain, where he was led by the extraordinary lisa fittko, following a harrowing climb into spain from france.warren leming

This is a compelling, well-written, and accessible biography of an uncompromising and enigmatic writer and public intellectual.I have been seeking such a literary biography to help me get a better handle on the influences and background to Benjamin's works such as Critique of Violence and the Arcades Project. The book provides this and much more, drawing judiciously on a multitude of sources, including his decades-long, sometimes prickly correspondence with dear friends. And what reader wouldn't be fascinated by his life? Without giving anything away, I can only say this biography offers surprising details and welcome nuances to the basic outline that many readers may already know. I think I will return to this book again and again in the coming years.

Really excited about this book, but it's too bad they made the dust jacket "soft touch." Semi-gloss is gross feeling. Giving the book away and getting it for Kindle instead.

Eiland and Jennings have produced a critical biography of Benjamin that stands a model of elegance. Their work is one of the finest examples of how scholarly writing can help the reader build understandings of even the densest philosophical and historical texts.

One of the truely most fascinating figures of the 20th century. And influential Critical Thinker who had virtualy gone unnotice during his own life time. Not unliked so many of the great intellectual artisans throughout history whose affect has been much later discuss and felt. His contribution to notion of Modernity, Technological Advancement and Art is so precient that its applicability even some 80 years later is very much relevant in this most chaotic of times. This is a Tribute not to just an extraodinary person but to a complex individual who refuse to be limited by the constraints of the societal norms of his constellation. I must and will take a much greater indebt view of his works.

As is freely admitted by Eiland & Jennings, Walter Benjamin is not the easiest of reads. This biography, securely anchored in Benjamin's writings, shines a bright, illuminating light on some of WB's most difficult works. Situating the texts in his specific life circumstances and in relation to his many illustrious interlocutors, these 2 Benjamin scholars have written one of the finest intellectual biographies of the postmodern period.

Ce livre comprend une description de la vie de Benjamin et aussi une analyse détaillée de son oeuvre, donc ceci explique la longueur de cette biographie (700 pages) et la difficulté à la lire pour quelqu'un qui ne connait pas la philosophie en général et les auteurs allemands en particuliers. Je dois admettre que j'ai sauté quelques passages particulièrement obscures écrits dans un language pédantique et technique.Par contre la vie de Benjamin traverse des temps dramatiques, les années 30, et le livre nous donne une idée de la vie difficile et même tragique que les artistes et intellectuels juifs et non juifs allemands ont mené pour survivre et fuir les Nazis.

J'ignore s'il existe une traduction française de cet œuvre remarquable. Sinon, il faudrait se hâter de le faire.La biographie de Benjamin d'Eiland a l'immense intérêt, au-delà d'un récit pondéré, distancié, et néanmoins chaleureux de la vie du philosophe, d'exposer avec clarté et un grand respect pour sa complexité, voire pour sa paradoxalité, sa pensée dans toute son envergure. C'est une lecture longue et exigeante mais qui vaut la peine que l'on se donne.J'ai abordé cette lecture suite à un "pèlerinage" sur les traces de Benjamin, qui nous a amenés à travers les Pyrénées de Banyuls à Port Bou, jusqu'au lieu où il se serait donné la mort en fuyant les Nazis. Nous l'avons accompagné alors avec nos corps par une torride journée d'été, nous l'avons accompagné avec notre esprit en lisant cette remarquable biographie.

Very well done. Gives very helpful sense of the flow of Benjamin's life and work as they were entwined together.