Allen Edmonds Men's Randolph Penny Loafer Dress Shoe

Allen Edmonds always produces a great fitting shoe. Workmanship and quality are first class. Purchased the shoe even though out of stock. Paid $265 on sale for the penny loafer which normally is $400. The shoe delivery was one week ahead of the projected delivery date. Shoe size is 13C which is a narrow width and hard to find. Allen Edmunds has a good selection in this size. The shoes are very comfortable durable and it fits right out of the box. No break in needed.

Nice quality but, a tight fit on one foot. I have an old pair of Brooks Brothers loafer but, newer versions are not the same quality. I tried these, hoping they would be the replacement I'm looking for - they didn't. I'll work with them, hope they loosen up I guess... Glad I don't have to wear these every day!!

I love Allen Edmond shoes, even though I do not purchase very often since I retired. I did recently buy the Randolph Penny Loafer in a size 11 N, and was pleased that the quality of Allen Edmond shoes still meets high standards. Also I am always very pleased to find a man's dress shoe in a narrow size. Even though I used to wear penny loafer's in high school, AE has modernized this classic shoe so it is stylish and looks good. These shoes will serve me well for many years.

The shoe size runs a little big. Not to horrible but I have to wear thicker socks with them. But then again they are Allen Edmonds enough said. Major quality shoes. I feel aristocratic when I wear them. LOL.

Color (coffee) is different than the picture and one shoe is noticeably looser fitting than the other. One fits great and one is pretty snug. I’m not sure if it’s clear from the picture, but the shoe I received is a lighter brown without the richness or depth of the one in the picture. I’m sure the size thing will correct a bit over time, but I’ve bought a lot of shoes, including Allen Edmonds, and this is a first.

Durable, comfortable, true to size

These shoes were not new as described. They were clearly worn already based on the wear on the soles and the imprint on the inside footbed. I will not be using this vendor again. I would have returned these shoes, but I was in a bit of a pinch and needed the shoes for a specific event and didn’t have the time to get a replacement pair.

Love these shoes and have been wearing 3 times a week for over a year. To the person saying they don't fit like their old shoes they need to realize that shoe companies use something called lasts that determine how they will fit. You find a last that fits your foot and then look for different styles that use that same last to ensure they will fit good.

Excellent price and saved money. Shoes were as described and brand new. Beautiful product. Fast shipping within Canada. Would definitely buy from the seller again.

Amazon return way too complicated. I can simply throw shoes in closet and forget about them and stop shopping Amazon

Nice shape and fit.

Top quality, craftsmanship, comfort and a timeless design. Expensive? Well, you get what you pay for.

I ordered a 10.5 wide, but it is still a narrow shoe.. Good for guys with narrow and slim feet.