Too Faced Killer Liner 36-Hour Gel Eyeliner Pencil | Long Lasting, Waterproof, Non-Flaking Eyeliner Pencil, 0.04 Ounce

Eyeliner is a critical part of my beauty routine. I often don’t wear shadow at all, just winged liner. So I’m very good at judging liner quality. Having mature skin further complicates my “perfect eyeliner” quest. I prefer the soft, gentle glide of potted gel liners. However, I find that it’s more difficult to apply a winged, sleek line with a brush. When I discovered that “Too Faced” now makes eyeliner, I knew it had to be good. This glassy slick gel pencil glides on beautifully AND lasts up to 36 hrs. I love it!!! I have removed this liner with a bit of Clinique brand “Take the Day Off” and a make up wipe (Neutrogena). In a pinch, just a wipe will suffice, tho it does tug a bit. Rich pigments tattoo your eyes with color and beautiful wings. Once easily applied, it must be removed. My tecnnique is great, but you don’t need anything special; just a steady hand. Colors are so good!! Deep, silky brown and midnight inky black. It’s always perfect and stays put until you take it off!

Best eyeliner ever. No smudges no raccoon eyes

Wold all day.

Best eyeliner! I love how smooth it goes on and no smudges. I will be purchasing it again.

After ordering 3 times from 2 different vendors and getting “Caramel” an ugly red brown instead of Espresso brown, I went to the manufacturer website. I don’t blame Amazon I blame their vendors who clearly don’t care. The Espresso is a nice dark brown but these pencils don’t work with a cheap sharpener. I ordered one made in Germany for about $10 and expect it will do a good job based on the reviews. Also these liners aren’t really that long. Since they are so dark I’m using them more when I go out and use the Maybelline unstoppable espresso for daywear.

Hi , the color is great , glides on nicely . The only complaint I have is that the liner is hard to sharpen without the tip breaking :/ I refrigerated it & still couldn’t get a good sharpen tip . Any suggestions ?

This eye pencil stays on forever! I have very oily irritable skin around my eyes and this is the most waterproof product I've ever used! It IS a little difficult to sharpen, but it's still worth it!

Update: This is not the eyeliner that I've used in the past. I didn't realize it was now a pencil enclosed in plastic, making it almost impossible to sharpen. Also, it dries out quickly and flakes off onto my face. For me, this is a waste of money. I use the black eyeliner, and like that the ingredients are safer than most other eyeliners out there, but unfortunately it doesn't last very long. If I apply it in the morning, by the afternoon the liner has dissolved a bit, leaving only a very thin line. Also, it's not a smooth application, sort of pulls on my eyelid and takes a while to build. Will keep using until I can find another safe alternative.

This liner did not stay on.. it smudges on both upper and lower lids..