Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Spread, 9 oz – Sweet Amish Peanut Butter with Marshmallow Flavor, Delicious on Ice Cream

Love this spread but wish it was in a different container. Hard to get iut

I was born and raised in Sarasota, Florida and had a dedicated Amish community. Naturally, every so often I get a craving for this stuff and don't want to drive 2hrs to get it. Luckily I did find this brand on Amazon and while the reviews about the bottle didn't seem promising, the confirmation of the taste was what I was really after. MY REVIEW: Yummy! This is the exact consistency/ Flavor I remember! As for the bottle... no issues! Once you open this, it should always be stored cap-side-down. This peanut butter is meant to be squeezed out like ketchup (but thicker obviously). Additionally, you should NEVER refrigerate this stuff! If people are complaining that they cant squeeze this stuff out, its most likely because they live in a colder area and/or they put this in the refrigerator and made it impossible to squeeze out. I think what also really helped is that I live in a warmer climate. All in all, very happy with this nostalgic purchase and I hope the Amazon community continues to purchase from this brand (I know I will)! ♡♡♡♡♡

The product itself is good. The bottle it comes in is the absolute worst! I think I got enough for one sandwich by squeezing it then I had to scrape the rest of it out with a knife which makes for a sticky mess. Will not reorder until there's a better bottle

This product looked like a good idea for a snack or sandwich ingredient, but it failed in storage/transit. Looks like the liquid sugar they are using pulls water from the peanut butter and so get to a water activity that allows yeast to grow in the material. The product arrived puffed up, and when the seal was removed it flowed out of the lid like a shaken can of soda. Very foamy. I am a food scientist and it looks like the product needs to be reformulated.

Just like what you would buy in the store except it came to the house!! We didn't have time to go to Amish Country to pick some up so we ordered it. Very good.

This didn’t taste like what I expected or would’ve expected from the description, and I’ve mixed pb and marshmallow fluff before…this didn’t taste like that. It’s kinda stringy and gloopy-hard. I don’t see any way you could spread it, and other reviewers are correct about how hard it is to get out of the bottle.

Novel gift

Awesome product. My 1 year old eats it with ease. Very smooth snd creamy!