L'Oreal Paris Lineur Intense Brush Tip Liquid Eyeliner, Carbon Black, 0.24 fl; oz.

This is the only liquid eyeliner I have used for the last 10 to 20 years easily. I’m sure the formula is changed over time but it has a very great glide with an amazing line quality you’re able to be very precise with it because it’s a thin, tiny paintbrush. Not the felt tip Which I don’t like. It dries quickly. At lasts all day long. And when I am using my make up remover, it comes off so easy you could even just get into the shower and splash water on your face and it would come off with the greatest of these. Clean up is a breeze

My favorite go to liner - goes on smooth and easy to make fine or thicker lines and brush tip flows like art.

I have been using this for longer than some of you have been alive. It is hands down my most favorite eyeliner ever. It is blacker than black, the line can taper so precisely and nicely and it stays. I have purchased some high end liners in my day but nothing ever compares. I always come back. I wouldn’t recommend this for beginners unless you are up for a challenge. Have a beautiful life, bye.

I’ve been using this eyeliner since highschool and I’ve had 30 years of people asking me how I get my cat eye so perf. I’ll never tell.

As long as you don’t touch your eyes this liner is great, and lasts. It will smudge and flake off if you touch your eyes though.

This is my go to eyeliner, the only one I'll ever use. Goes on smooth and stays all day.

Love this, but I think it is discontinued.

My go to eyeliner!

This is the best eyeliner ever. If you're any good with a brush applicator then you won't have any problem. The pigment is dense and it lasts forever! You can litteraly put it on in the morning, go on with your day, go to the gym (and train like a beast) and then shower (don't shove your face directly into the water, obviously) and then go on date, have proper fun and go to sleep, and it will still look on point the next day!!!! Of course it will not be as on point as freshly applied eyeliner, but for makeup from the day before... it's pretty good, I wouldn't be ashamed to go straight to work. I don't recommend crying while wearing it but if you do, your face won't be all black... I've been using it for years, nothing compares.

I’ve been wearing this eyeliner for many many years and only in the last year have I noticed they changed the formula. It does not say that it’s waterproof but after it dries — it peels off like vinyl and it’s impossible to get off. I often have pieces left on my eyelids in the morning. I have to scratch them off because my makeup remover can’t get it off. I really dislike this formula.

I have been using Loreal liquid eyeliner for a long time and swear by it. Usually I get the felt tip and by accident this time purchased the brush. It still does a nice job but goes on a little too thick for my liking. It was also very difficult to get in and out of the base. This has made for a couple of minor messes. I most certainly will make use of the product as like the felt tip it goes on effortlessly, does not run or smudge, is easy to remove and best of all causes no adverse affects to the eyes.l I will continue to use L'Oreal products as it is a name I trust and have used many other of their products.

I have one of these that I have had for several years. I was not in good health for a year but used the product pretty often the other 2 years. It has not dried up and I finally just ordered new eye liner thinking that the older one will run out soon. I hate to throw it out as I am curious to see how much longer it will last. Good Bang for your Buck! I hate the hard tip that most other companies put out. The brush tip gives you much more control on application. The eye liner has great staying power after application. I am amazed that the bottle that is 3 years old is not sticky or too thick. Still goes on smooth and slick.

I've been looking for an alternate to the Annabelle liquid liner as the brush is really thin to create easy and elegant strokes compared to other eyeliner brushes or types. Unfortunately this brush sucks, there's no point at the tip and it's like a thin painters brush you get at the dollar store. The formula is okay but I don't think it's worth repurchasing.