lakyou beauty colored waterproof eyeliner pen black (low price)

It comes off easily after a few hours. Doesn't smudge but if you rub the eye it will come off. Doesn't leave the eye black. It's expensive for something that doesn't last so long. Has a shine

Long lasting. Stay up to 10 hour. Very beautifully.

Awesome quality.

Good....

Pathetic.... Not at alll waterproof

Ordered 2. Both are leaking and are not usable.